**

Ireland's Finance Minister, Paschal Donohoe, has defended the government's decision not to include a repeat of the substantial cost-of-living payments in the upcoming Budget 2024, sparking a wave of criticism from opposition parties and social welfare advocacy groups. The announcement, made amidst persistent inflationary pressures and a looming winter, has ignited a heated public debate on the government's economic strategy and its impact on vulnerable households facing escalating energy bills and the rising cost of essential goods. This decision comes against a backdrop of ongoing concerns about the cost of living crisis Ireland, inflation Ireland, and the impact of inflation on household incomes.

Budget 2024: The Key Omissions and the Rationale

The absence of widespread cost-of-living payments in Budget 2024 has been the most contentious aspect of the pre-budget announcements. Donohoe justified the decision by highlighting the government's commitment to fiscal prudence and a need to manage the national debt. He emphasized that significant support measures have already been implemented in previous budgets, amounting to billions of euros in targeted assistance and broader tax cuts aimed at alleviating financial pressures on families.

Targeted Support vs. Universal Payments: A Balancing Act?

The government argues that a more targeted approach to financial support is more fiscally responsible and effective. Instead of blanket cost-of-living payments, Budget 2024 is expected to focus on:

• Targeted energy supports: Measures such as continued energy credits and potential schemes aimed at assisting low-income households with their energy bills are likely to feature prominently. These schemes are designed to directly address the immediate impact of high energy prices.
• Tax adjustments: The government may introduce adjustments to tax bands or rates, aiming to provide relief for middle-income earners while maintaining fiscal responsibility.
• Social welfare enhancements: While not mirroring the scale of the past cost-of-living payments, specific increases to certain social welfare payments are anticipated.
• Investment in infrastructure and employment: A significant portion of the budget is expected to be allocated to investments aimed at boosting the Irish economy, creating jobs, and improving essential public services. The government argues that these long-term investments are crucial for sustainable economic growth and future prosperity.

The Criticism Mounts

Despite the government's justifications, opposition parties have been quick to condemn the decision. They argue that the current level of inflation and the ongoing cost-of-living crisis necessitate further widespread financial support for households. The lack of universal cost-of-living payments is seen by critics as a significant failure to adequately address the plight of many struggling families.

• Sinn Féin, the largest opposition party, has called for a substantial increase in social welfare payments and a significant expansion of targeted supports to ensure everyone can meet their essential needs.
• The Social Democrats have criticized the government's focus on fiscal responsibility at the expense of addressing the urgent needs of struggling families and individuals. They argue that a more proactive and generous approach is required.
• People Before Profit has been particularly vocal, accusing the government of prioritizing austerity measures over the well-being of the most vulnerable members of society. They’ve called for a massive increase in welfare payments and rent controls.

The Economic Context: Navigating Inflation and Debt

Donohoe's defense rests heavily on the need to manage public finances responsibly in the face of ongoing inflationary pressures and the need to reduce Ireland’s national debt. He argues that while the government is committed to supporting citizens, reckless spending could destabilize the economy in the long term.

The government points to factors beyond its control, such as global inflation and the ongoing war in Ukraine, as contributing factors to the challenging economic climate. They maintain that the planned budget measures strike a careful balance between providing assistance and maintaining fiscal sustainability.

However, critics argue that the government could afford more substantial support measures without compromising fiscal responsibility. They point to the significant corporate tax revenues Ireland receives and suggest that a more progressive approach to taxation and redistribution of wealth could provide additional funds for social welfare programs.

Public Opinion and the Road Ahead

Public opinion remains divided. While some understand the government's concerns about fiscal responsibility, many feel the measures proposed are insufficient to address the harsh realities faced by those struggling to make ends meet. This is particularly true given the high cost of housing in Ireland and the challenges facing renters. Public opinion polls continue to reflect a significant level of public dissatisfaction with the government's handling of the cost of living crisis.

The coming weeks will be crucial as the budget is finalized and debated. The government will be under immense pressure to justify its approach and to demonstrate its commitment to supporting those most affected by the ongoing cost-of-living crisis. The upcoming budget will be pivotal in determining the government’s economic legacy and its ability to navigate the complex challenges of inflation and social welfare in the face of rising public dissatisfaction. The debate around Budget 2024 and its impact on the Irish economy and the welfare of Irish citizens is far from over. The government's response to public concerns will be closely scrutinized in the coming months.